As Economic Struggles Rise, Planning Plummets

Instead, a majority of Americans are now managing their finances reactively. Rather than plan for future financial difficulties, they address these issues as they arise. This trend, highlighted in recent research by PYMNTS Intelligence (PYMNTS), reveals not only a change in behavior but also a deepening vulnerability across all income levels and age groups.

According to the PYMNTS research, just 40% of Americans are categorized as “planners.” These individuals are characterized by their proactive approach to money management: they pay off credit card balances in full, maintain a savings buffer of at least $2,500, and generally take steps to anticipate and prepare for financial challenges.

This represents a significant drop, as this figure was closer to 50% in February of 2024. This signals a significant shift in the nation’s financial mindset. The remaining 60% of Americans now fall into the category of “reactors,” a group that manages money on a more ad hoc basis, often relying on credit and carrying higher balances.

Reactionary Approaches on the Rise

The majority of Americans, now identified as reactors, are defined by their tendency to address financial obligations only as they arise. Rather than planning ahead, these individuals often find themselves reacting to emergencies, unexpected expenses, or debt payments. This reactive approach is closely linked to higher credit card balances and lower levels of savings.

This shift is not just a matter of personal preference. It is a response to the economic realities facing many households. Rising costs of living, inflation, and economic uncertainty have made it increasingly difficult for Americans to set aside money for the future. As a result, even those who once prided themselves on their financial discipline are finding it harder to maintain proactive habits.

Generational and Income-Based Shifts

The research also revealed several surprising trends across various generational groups. While it might be expected that younger generations would be more likely to manage their finances reactively, the data reveals that this trend is spreading across all age groups and income brackets. Among Baby Boomers, 54% still identify as planners, but 73% of Generation Z now consider themselves reactors. This generational divide highlights the differing priorities between older and younger Americans. Boomers seek financial stability, while members of Gen Z are more willing to take risks, with 6.8% listing one of their top financial goals as “starting a business.”

How to Address the Increase in Reactionary Planning

As a result of this significant drop in American consumers planning ahead for financial difficulties, larger quantities of Americans lack emergency savings and would likely face sizable struggles when these financial difficulties inevitably arise.

Fortunately, there are courses of action that can be taken to alleviate these issues. Consumers can make efforts to increase their financial literacy and develop support systems that help them navigate economic challenges.

One such measure is working with a financial advisor. Financial advisors can assist clients in increasing their financial literacy and working with them to construct a comprehensive financial plan that accounts for current shortcomings while setting and meeting goals for the future.

As for advisors, it can be important to understand what type of planner a client is, whether that be proactive or reactive. Understanding the mentality of a client often allows advisors to determine the best ways to communicate with their clients and help them achieve their goals.

Learning concepts such as behavioral finance, which are addressed in The American College of Financial Services’ Master of Science in Financial Planning (MSFP) program, can provide advisors with the knowledge they need to effectively work with clients of all kinds and help them devise a plan that is best suited to their approach towards financial planning.

What This Means

Ultimately, the financial habits of Americans are undergoing a profound transformation. As economic pressures mount, more people are abandoning proactive financial planning in favor of reactive money management. This trend is evident across generations and income levels, highlighting a growing vulnerability. As such, the nation’s financial health depends on our ability to adapt, educate, and support one another in building a more secure future. The overarching message is unmistakable — without a renewed focus on financial literacy and proactive planning, Americans will remain at risk, ill-prepared for the uncertainties that lie ahead.

More From The College

• More research about economic uncertainty
• Learn more about behavioral finance with the MSFP Program
• See more research from The College