The question posed to me as the business ethicist on the panel by the moderator, Prof. Robert Barrington, was whether it is realistic to expect that a lawyer, as a professional service provider, should be a guardian of ethics, operating in the public interest? Or are they just technicians, implementing laws made by others? 

This ethical duty of lawyers plays out differently depending on the context of the client representation. The U.S.constitutional right to counsel in criminal cases does not extend to civil litigation or corporate transactions. Thus, while criminal lawyers can answer with a resounding “yes” about their ethical duties to represent any client who seeks guidance, the nuances of corporate and civil representation raise distinct questions. 

In recent years, globalization together with the rise of global sanctions on financial and business activities challenges law firms to consider whether they will take on as clients individuals and companies considered “corrupt,” or otherwise violating internal business norms or global anti-money laundering (AML) regimes. Personal and corporate transactions such as trust and estates, real estate purchases, or mergers and acquisitions for clients whose funds may be of illicit origins raise unique ethical dilemmas. 

As Robert Barrington and Georgia Garrod summarize, the AML laws identify criminal activities as those that are illegal inthe country of origin. Thus, acts occurring in jurisdictions with weak rule of law or limited criminal enforcement result ininsufficient evidence and proof of wrongdoing to address U.S. or U.K. procedures. Addressing this gap in AML regimes,and how it relates to the duties of lawyers, is on the agenda for both governments with upcoming reforms. See, e.g., U.S. Strategy on Countering Corruption (December 2021) (policies will determine whether “key gatekeepers to the financial system—including lawyers, accountants, and trust and company service providers—cannot evade scrutiny”). 

Moreover, the rules of professional responsibility provide limited guidance in the context of civil law, leaving a vacuum to be addressed by lawyers on a case-by-case basis. Lawyers and law firms therefore need to clarify their ethical duties based on corporate and personal values. For instance, when does substantive representation of an otherwise unseemly clients help a client stay on the right side of the law, versus situations where they are thwarting the law? How do we define what is in the public interest? 

Importantly, firms and leaders need to create environments where it is common and appropriate that lawyers, from junior associates to senior partners, raise ethics concerns about the balance between access to justice and those representations that may in the long run thwart justice. While lawyers may be trained to argue “both” sides of an issue, in practice, personal and professional ethics can guide which representations they wish to pursue. 

The short answer to Professor Barrington’s question about the whether lawyers can be guardians of ethics is yes, they can and should be, but we have some work to do as a legal community to identify the right guidance and processes to embrace this role. 

Reprinted with permission from the January 2023 edition of the “New York Law Journal,” © 2023 ALM Global Properties, LLC. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. Contact 877-256-2472 or reprints@alm.com.

Filabi also serves as the executive director of the American College Maguire Center for Ethics in Financial Services. The interview focuses on the findings of the Center’s “Trust in Financial Services” research, published in 2022.

Read the full article here.

This column was originally published in the Journal of Financial Service Professionals, Vol. 77, no. 2, pp. 37-39. Copyright © 2023 by the Society of Financial Service Professionals. All rights reserved.

Whether this is your first designation or another step in your learning journey, you’ve reached an important academic milestone — and we salute you. You’ve also gained access to many valuable tools that can further accelerate your professional growth. You can find the full breakdown of all these resources below.

Professional Recertification Program

As a College designee, you are now part of our Professional Recertification Program (PRP). With your annual renewal fee, you get:

• Free ongoing access to Knowledge Hub+: Your home for CE and just-in-time learning on an on-demand platform
• Discounts to in-person educational events and conferences
• Advisor Toolkits to help you demonstrate your value to clients
• Another pathway to lead generation through a partnership with Couplr.AI
• Creation of a free profile on our redesigned consumer search tool YourAdvisorGuide.com

Log into your Learning Hub profile now to take advantage of these PRP benefits!

Get Started

Promote Your Accomplishments

There are many ways you can spread the word about your latest designation or certification. Start by logging into your Learning Hub profile to view your award letter on the “My Designations and Certifications” page; then, you can:

• Share your digital badge on social media or in your email signature to showcase your accomplishments
• Frame your credentials! Visit our framing partner for styles, pricing, and shipping options (diplomas delivered separately); Huebner School diplomas are 11x14 inches, and graduate school diplomas are 8.5x11 inches
• Review branding guidelines for promoting your designation
• Get digital and print materials to showcase your commitment to knowledge with your Designation Toolkit
• Show your College pride by browsing our School Store! Choose from a wide selection of high-quality College-branded merchandise including apparel, mugs, travel bags, and more!

Take Your Next Step

Learning never stops — so why should you? Continue your pursuit of lifelong learning with another course or program from The College!

• Review the Designation Overview Guide to see all currently available programs, including how stackable course requirements can help you finish faster!
• Take a deeper look at how The College facilitates your lifelong learning journey and ongoing growth
• See the impact of the designations you’ve received on your peers’ business — and how additional designations can power your growth
• Attend a College event for further opportunities for professional development and networking

Giving Back

If you’d like to pay forward how The College has supported your growth and help other financial professionals do the same — as well as shaping the future of society at large — you can support our mission in various ways:

• Give directly to The College to support a chosen scholarship, Center of Excellence, event, or impact initiative
• Visit our Centers of Excellence to learn more about their missions and engage with them through their programs and events

Learn more about the resources available to you as a valued College alum.